Pay compliance is everyone’s job: Lessons from NAB’s record Enforceable Undertaking
When a payroll problem goes unresolved for more than a decade, it is no longer a technical glitch. It is an organisational failure.
The Fair Work Ombudsman’s Enforceable Undertaking with National Australia Bank (NAB) makes that clear, and it sets new expectations for how employers prepare for an enterprise agreement renegotiation.
What happened
NAB is completing payments of $127 million, plus $34 million in interest and $8 million in superannuation, to 65,999 underpaid workers under its Enforceable Undertaking with the Fair Work Ombudsman. The bank will also make a $2 million contrition payment to the Commonwealth Consolidated Revenue Fund, the largest contrition payment the regulator has ever included in an undertaking.
The underpayments were widespread. Workers in every state and territory were affected. Individual back-payments range from under $5 to more than $87,000, and the average is about $1,934. Casual, part-time, and full-time staff across personal and business banking were underpaid, from customer support advisors to branch managers and project managers.
Almost every type of entitlement was affected, including minimum wages, penalty rates, shift loadings, overtime, allowances, termination payments, leave entitlements and superannuation.
How it unfolded
NAB first reported itself to the regulator in late 2019, after finding significant errors in how it had implemented its enterprise agreement. A broader review then uncovered non-compliance dating back to 2012.
The story didn’t end there. When NAB rolled out a new enterprise agreement in 2024, it found it had not adequately identified and fixed the earlier problems, so staff were still being underpaid. The underpayments ran from 2012 to 2026. NAB has now fixed most of them and has paid at least $155 million to current and former employees so far.
What went wrong
The regulator identified four underlying causes:
- weak governance processes and compliance oversight
- inadequate record-keeping
- legacy payroll technology; and
- limited investment in specialist payroll capability.
Those weaknesses lead to some basic failures:
- NAB didn’t run the regular reconciliation checks its own enterprise agreement required. These checks compare wages paid with what employees would have received under the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010, so any shortfall can be paid.
- Time-and-attendance data wasn’t adequately captured.
- Staff leave wasn’t accrued correctly.
- Various entitlements were misapplied, or not applied at all, under successive enterprise agreements.
The most telling point is that NAB had built protections into its own agreement but didn’t use them. The regulator also criticised the bank for agreeing to enforceable terms without first making sure its payroll systems could deliver them.
The regulator's message
Fair Work Ombudsman Anna Booth said NAB’s case shows the serious, long-running problems that can follow when an employer fails to coordinate the business functions responsible for meeting workplace obligations: payroll, industrial relations, technology, risk management, audit and legal.
Her central message was that complying with workplace laws is an organisation-wide responsibility, and that planning to comply with new agreement terms should start early.
The regulator accepted an undertaking rather than going to court because NAB had cooperated with the investigation, committed to fully fixing the underpayments and agreed to strengthen its compliance and governance. The undertaking also requires remediation for periods well beyond the usual statutory time limits.
What NAB has committed to
The undertaking includes terms the Fair Work Ombudsman has never used before. For the first time, an employer must plan early to implement any new enterprise agreement. NAB’s planning will run through a steering committee chaired by its Group Executive People and Culture. The committee will oversee how the agreement is put into operation, including whether the bank’s systems and processes can deliver every requirement before it starts.
NAB has also committed to:
- an independent audit of its new payroll platform, with the findings reported to the regulator
- better systems for spotting non-compliance trends in employee complaints, and for tracking each complaint from receipt to resolution, including response times
- worker-voice initiatives, including regular staff forums and promoting the channels employees can use to raise concerns
- a broader payroll review, overseen by Group Executives, with any further underpayments fixed
- regular reporting to the board on compliance matters
- sharing what it has learned about workplace relations compliance with the rest of the industry
- mandatory training on recording additional hours worked, and on any new agreement
- telling employees about the undertaking publicly and giving current staff a further written apology.
Key lessons for employers
- Plan for compliance before the agreement is finalised. Many organisations start configuring payroll after an agreement has been approved. NAB now has to confirm its systems can deliver the agreement while it is still being planned. Every employer heading into bargaining should ask the same question before agreeing to new terms: can our payroll actually do this?
- Make compliance an organisation-wide responsibility. The regulator traced NAB’s problems to poor coordination between payroll, industrial relations, technology, risk, audit and legal. Give a senior executive accountability for agreement readiness, and involve all of these functions from the start.
- Use the safeguards you already have. If your agreement requires reconciliation checks, run them on schedule, record them and pay any shortfall. A safeguard that isn’t used provides no protection.
- Capture every hour worked. Poor time-and-attendance data was one of NAB’s basic failures. Make sure your systems record all hours, including additional hours worked by salaried staff, and train employees and managers to record them accurately.
- Get the fundamentals right. Leave accruals, allowances and penalty rates are routine. When they go wrong at scale, the cost adds up quickly. Audit them regularly, especially after a system change or a new agreement.
- Treat employee complaints as an early warning. A single complaint may be an isolated error, but a pattern points to a systemic problem. Track complaints from receipt to resolution, watch for trends, and make sure senior leaders see what is being raised.
- Give employees a voice. Staff forums and clear channels for raising concerns help problems surface early. An organisation where people feel safe speaking up is more likely to find issues before a regulator does.
- Keep the board informed. Pay compliance is a governance matter. Regular, structured reporting to the board means risks are seen and acted on at the right level.
- Act decisively when you find a problem. Self-reporting and cooperation counted in NAB’s favour. However, NAB’s failure to fully fix its problems after the 2019 report led to years of further underpayments. If you find an issue, fix it thoroughly and check that the fix worked. The Fair Work Ombudsman’s Payroll Remediation Program Guide is a practical place to start.
How Mapien can help
Pay compliance sits where systems, governance and workplace culture meet. Mapien works with employers to review workplace practices, strengthen governance frameworks and investigate concerns raised by employees, so that small issues are dealt with before they become systemic.
If you’re preparing for a bargaining round, or want to test how well your organisation listens to and acts on employee concerns, please contact us below and one of Workplace Strategists will be in touch within 24 hours.